Bats learn sounds from each other: an interview with Dr. Ella Lattenkamp

/

Dr. Ella Lattenkamp was a PhD student at the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics and the Ludwig-Maximilians University Munich. She defended her thesis entitled ‘Vocal Learning in the Pale Spear-Nosed Bat, Phyllostomus discolor’ on April 23 2020.

1. What was the main question in your dissertation?
In my dissertation, I investigated the vocal learning capacity of the pale spear-nosed bat (see picture above).

2. Can you explain the (theoretical) background a bit more?

Ella Lattenkamp
Humans are exceptionally good vocal learners. This means that they can easily copy and learn sounds, such as words, from others. This enables us to learn languages and communicate complex matters via speech. No other animal species shows a comparable vocal learning ability, but some show the capacity to some extent. Prominent examples are parrots and other songbirds, such as lyre birds or even ravens. Only a few mammals have shown this capacity, including whales, seals, and elephants. Bats, too, have been shown to possess the capacity for vocal learning, but the trait has not been investigated in detail in a single bat species before. In my thesis I studied one particular bat species (Phyllostomus discolor, the pale spear-nosed bat), which has previously shown indications for vocal learning. For example, bat pups are known to copy mothers’ calls.

3. Why is it important to answer this question?
Studying vocal learning in other mammalian species is important to understand the evolutionary basis of the human capacity for speech acquisition. So far most investigative efforts were focused on studying songbirds (especially zebra finches). Mammals have received far less attention.

4. Can you tell us about one particular project?
The key experiment of my dissertation was designed to discover whether pale spear-nosed bats can learn to lower the pitch of their calls. For that, the bats were trained in isolation in little “bat recording studios”. They had to move towards a light-barrier (ed. like a laser beam), which they interrupted by putting their wings, nose, or feet in the light beam. After that, they were presented with the playback of their own calls. In this playback, the pitch of their calls was lower. The bats were rewarded if they then copied the call with this lower pitch. We found that all tested bats lowered the pitch of their calls within 30 days of training and in a follow-up experiment, we showed that at least one of them did this regardless of whether it received a reward. The results demonstrate that the pale spear-nosed bat is capable of vocal learning.

5. What was your most interesting/ important finding?
I published five chapters in my thesis, which are quite diverse and include an opinion paper, two behavioural experimental studies (as the study described above), but also a vocal repertoire description and a cross-species comparison of the hearing capacity of tropical bat species. So it is hard to say which finding is the most important or interesting, as that depends which field you are in and which question you are trying to answer. However, the finding that received most attention in the press is the demonstration of the vocal learning capacity of the pale spear-nosed bat under controlled laboratory conditions (described above).

6. What are the consequences/ implications of this finding? How does this push science or society forward?
This finding is interesting in itself and allows follow-up studies investigating the vocal learning capacities of other bat species. It also allows the within and across species comparison of the vocal learning capacityin different species (mammals and birds). This way it paves the way to eventually being able to trace the evolution and biological basis of speech acquisition in humans.

7. What do you want to do next?
After I finished my PhD, I started working for a charitable nonprofit foundation  concerned with the support of financially disadvantaged children worldwide. We promote and enable access to basic health care as well as education and training. On the side, I still work on the open projects from my PhD and enjoy science, at least for a while, from a distance.

 

Read more
Link to dissertation

 

Header picture Phyllostomus discolor: Karin Schneeberger, recoloured by WolfmanSF, via Wikimedia Commons

 

Interviewer: Merel Wolf
Editor: Julia Egger
Dutch translation: Eva Poort
Germantranslation: Natalia Levshina
Final editing: Merel Wolf

FacebookTwitterEmailLinkedInWhatsApp